Results 1 to 17 of 17

Thread: Not Half Bad...But A Bad Half!

  1. #1
    Veteran Member Bell-Two's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jul 2010
    Location
    South West Ohio
    Posts
    1,720

    Not Half Bad...But A Bad Half!

    Went out yesterday to take advantage of the first dry day we have had in the last three. Since I figured the fields that have been turned would be very muddy I returned to the cornfield where I got the Large Cent the other day. My first find there was a button that turned out to be a beautiful Benedict & Burnham flower button. The Benedict & Burnham buttons were always of a high quality and nicely designed. The company was in existence from 1835 to 1840.





    I then found a part of a pocket watch and two suspender buckles.









    I then found a copper disk with a chunk out of it at first I thought it might have been some kind of tag or fob but after getting it home and cleaning it a bit I had suspicions it may be more than that. I saw what I felt was a left facing bust and the back had an image that appeared to be an eagle. After cleaning and applying a light coat of olive oil the images were a bit clearer. I turned to Dave Wise know on the forums as Heavymetalnut, I posted him via face book a couple of pictures and within a couple of minutes he came back with the answer, a Counterfeit Capped Bust Half Dollar! I then sent pictures to an official of the Contemporary Counterfeit Half Dollar Club….yes there is such a club…. He sent me an e-mail confirming that it was a Counterfeit Half. A bit later he said he did some further research and based on what he saw of the bust and the positioning of motto bar that has the E Pluribus Unum motto he believes it is the rare one. He stated:

    Tony, I love a challenge and did a bit more research on you contemporary counterfeit Capped Bust Half based upon the attributes of the partial facial profile of Liberty on the obverse and the eagle's elongated neck plus alignment of the slogan bar to the letter M of the edge's legend on the reverse. There is likelihood that it could be known as an 1834 17/Q variety (i.e. rare with only two specimens currently known)! Look at the website location at http://cccbhcc.com/2nd-edition-error...tml#1834%2017Q

    It looks as though this may have been a neck piece the hole at the edge of the fracture looks rounded. In person the bust is even more discernable as are the stars around the edge.



    The image on reverse is easier to see, clearly an eagle and the lettering in America is discernable when slightly tilted.



    I then went to a field I call the “Iron Field” which has given us many great finds. I wanted to try out my new Tesoro Cibola, the Tesoro’s are lightning fast and can pick out a target next to iron. I did not find anything significant with it but will try it again, as there were parts of this soybean field that were too muddy to walk in. I did make a good find with my eyes, an 1865 Indian Head lying on top of the ground. The heavy rains that we have had washed it out along with even more brick and glass.



    Psalms 24:1 ¶ The earth is the LORD'S, and all it contains...But God shares with us who search!
    Member Dayton Diggers CTX 3030- Minelab E-Trac


    click here to view my finds album

  2. #2
    that's just awesome Tony! amazing piece of history ! congrats!
    2008-14 coppers
    2009-32 coppers
    2010-34 coppers 2-GW buttons
    2011- 80 & 3/4 coppers 1-GW button
    2012- 92 coppers/large cents 1-GW button
    2013- 57 1/4 coppers 6- GW Buttons
    2014- 69 coppers 1-GW button
    2015- 20 1/4 coppers
    2016-44 coppers 1-GW button
    2017-19 & 1/2 coppers
    2018-19 coppers 1-GW
    2019-5 coppers
    click to see my photo album

  3. #3
    Senior Member Isaac's Avatar
    Join Date
    May 2014
    Location
    Herndon Virginia
    Posts
    731
    That counterfeit capped bust half dollar is the sheeeezzzz ! Congrats on a spectacular find!!! It's going to be hard to top that man!!! looks like it was worn as a necklace and not on a string either because of that it broke off... the whole chunk of coin came off from the weight of the necklace ... it must've been a really brittle type metal
    Last edited by Isaac; 12-09-2014 at 02:33 PM.
    I <3 colonial relics!

  4. #4
    Global Moderator aloldstuff's Avatar
    Join Date
    Mar 2011
    Location
    western mass
    Posts
    10,310
    A counterfeit half dollar club?????? What else can I learn on this forum???? Thanks for the lesson on counterfeit half dollars and what a great find. Hope your fields dry out soon.
    V3i- Prism IV- Pro Pointer
    2020 GOAL: Any Flowing Hair coin

    TOTAL 100 YEAR OLD COINS - -280
    2020:
    Silver: 11


    Oldest U.S. Copper - 1795 Liberty Cap
    Oldest U.S. Silver - 1829 Capped Bust Dime extra large 10C
    Click here to view my album

  5. #5
    Veteran Member BTV Digger's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jan 2014
    Location
    Northern Vermont
    Posts
    1,876
    Awesome old coin Tony! Had to chuckle on the Counterfeit Half Dollar Club. Can't imagine they have a huge membership...you should consider joining!

    John
    Vermont relic hunting, one swing at a time.
    https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCG2...OLib30A/videos

  6. #6
    Those are some really interesting finds Tony. The buckles sure look 1800s and of course the fake half dollar is a real good find. On those old gilt buttons if you lightly brush a little CLR on it and rinse immediately, they really shine up nice (you probably know that though). Congrats and HH, Dave.
    Oldest Coin: 100-60 BC Gallic bronze coin (Sequani Tribe)
    Oldest Silver Coin: 1156 hammered Pfennig from (now) Bavaria
    Oldest U.S. coin: 1805 Draped Bust Large Cent
    Best Coins EVER: 1625 4 Sols from Kingdom of Chateau Renaud, France
    1662 15 Kreuzers, Leopold I, Austria
    Best Relics: Bronze Age Arrowheads & Spearhead, 2c Roman silver ring, complete medieval knight's spur (x6)
    YouTube Channel: Full Metal Digger

  7. #7
    Senior Member Nesdore's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jun 2014
    Location
    Southeastern Ohio
    Posts
    615
    WOW congrats Tony great hunt awesome counterfeit half dollar nice looking Indian
    Oldest Coin - 1830 Large Cent
    Oldest Silver - 1898 Barber Dime

    Garrett Ace 350, Garrett AT Pro Pointer

  8. #8
    Fantastic piece Tony! Congrats on a very nice score. Love that button too.
    Slow digging is better than no digging.
    Whites V3i, MXT, Garrett Pro Pointer, Sampson 31" T-handle shovel.
    AD members detected with: del, OxShoeDrew, RobW, Massdirtfisher, Mango Ave, Lee, chrisinct, aloldstuff, HEAVYMETALNUT, Thiltzy

  9. #9
    Veteran Member Bell-Two's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jul 2010
    Location
    South West Ohio
    Posts
    1,720
    Quote Originally Posted by DaddyDigger View Post
    Those are some really interesting finds Tony. The buckles sure look 1800s and of course the fake half dollar is a real good find. On those old gilt buttons if you lightly brush a little CLR on it and rinse immediately, they really shine up nice (you probably know that though). Congrats and HH, Dave.
    exactly how I cleaned it Dave! Yes I use a 50/50 mixture of CLR and water, brush and rinse, brush and rinse.
    Psalms 24:1 ¶ The earth is the LORD'S, and all it contains...But God shares with us who search!
    Member Dayton Diggers CTX 3030- Minelab E-Trac


    click here to view my finds album

  10. #10
    Administrator del's Avatar
    Join Date
    Oct 2009
    Location
    Connecticut
    Posts
    13,015
    Tony I first saw this button on facebook , its a great example from the "golden age" very nice one piece love the counterfeit capped bust half too. very nice finds
    "Honesty is an expensive gift ,
    so don't expect it from cheap people"

    XP Deus II , DFX ,TDI sl -

    Click here to view my finds album


  11. #11
    In this instance a bad half turned out to be very good!

    That counterfeit half dollar is a fascinating find, Tony! Much more rare than an authentic bust half. Obviously it was silver plated at one time. That Counterfeit Capped Bust Half Collectors Club website is very interesting too. Some of the counterfeits are very crude, others are very convincing.

    Nice button and 1865 Indian Head too!

    Congrats on the fantastic finds!
    Lifetime totals:
    10 Large Cents, 415 Indian Heads, 2 Two Cent Pieces, 1 Capped Bust Half Dime, 1 Seated Half Dime, 10 Shield Nickels, 68 V Nickels, 124 Buffalo Nickels, 31 War Nickels, 16 Seated Dimes, 131 Barber Dimes, 405 Mercury Dimes, 249 Rosies, 4 Seated Quarters, 18 Barber Quarters, 20 Standing Liberty Quarters, 89 Silver Washingtons, 1 Seated Half, 3 Barber Halves, 16 Walking Liberty Halves

    YouTube Channel: Tony Two-Cent https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCmz...RlHTBIU42bUORg

  12. #12
    Great finds. Love that bad half!
    Oldest find: 5,000 year old copper spearhead
    Oldest coin: 1699 William III halfpenny
    Purdiest coin: 1832 Capped Bust quarter
    Coolest find: USA button with blue threads still on shank

    "He who would search for pearls must dive below."

  13. #13
    Impressive Tony, do you keep all your counterfeit halfs in one box?
    On Instagram- oxshoedrew

  14. #14
    Veteran Member Bell-Two's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jul 2010
    Location
    South West Ohio
    Posts
    1,720
    Quote Originally Posted by OxShoeDrew View Post
    Impressive Tony, do you keep all your counterfeit halfs in one box?

    Drew I keep Half in one box and Half in another!
    Psalms 24:1 ¶ The earth is the LORD'S, and all it contains...But God shares with us who search!
    Member Dayton Diggers CTX 3030- Minelab E-Trac


    click here to view my finds album

  15. #15
    Elite Member giant056's Avatar
    Join Date
    Dec 2010
    Location
    Kalamazoo Michigan
    Posts
    2,645
    Very cool old counterfit great bunch of finds

  16. #16
    Sweet oldies Tony. WTG
    MXT Pro, Garrett Pro Pointer, 5.3 & and 950 coils, Sun Ray Pro Gold HP, Excalibur , 1000 coil, 2, Whites Dual Field PIs, Sovereign GT

    Oldest Silver: 17?2 Half Reale

    Oldest Coins: 1723 Halfpenny ,1729- ? KG 2rd Half Penny, 1786 Connecticut Copper, 1787 Fugio.

    11@ 1807,8 Reale Counterfeit Cache

  17. #17
    That's awesome! Great finds!!
    I found a counterfeit trade dollar, years ago...They are certainly exciting finds!

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •