Well, I hope I didn't use up a lifetime's worth of luck with my one honey hole. First I went off to the sites I located as an 1850's era grist mill and saw mill, as well as a blacksmith shop, tavern and inn. I could pretty much verify it was the right location by finding a few square nails, and some kind of tag with an 1871 date, but nothing else in the region even close to being from that era. Found tons of fishing sinkers, garbage and pull tabs, but not a single coin-not even clad! Very unusual...
Secondly I went to the first public park in the city, a very small square that dated back to 1837. Once again, after several hours I found nothing but a few clad, a couple newer pennies and tons of pull tabs. Nothing older than around 1987-so what gives-someone hunted it out earlier maybe? I would have guessed a minimum of a couple Wheaties at least!
Lastly, went out for a couple hours today to another park location expecting to at least find some decent amount of clad. Two hours later I had 2 quarters and a penny-go figure.
My question is how often does everyone get these nasty dry spells? Or is it more a rule than the exception
Update-the "tag" mentioned above was now identified as actually being a suspender clip, so actually one nice find!