Congrats on what I'm sure will be the first of many Indian Head Cents for you this year. I love that cigar token! I found that cigar store in the annual inspection reports from 1901 and 1913. I bet your token dates from that era.
I love tokens because the first 10 years of metal detecting for me was in an area rich in tokens (coal camps). I always loved the aluminum ones because, sometimes, they come out of the ground looking like yours. Great find.